The best retractable makeup pens pair convenient twist-up use with a formula and tip suited to the job. My best overall pick is the Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Eyeliner for a straightforward, waterproof everyday liner; NYX Mechanical Lip Liner is the standout when you want a dedicated lip pencil, while IT Cosmetics Superhero is the premium option. The main tradeoffs are single-color precision versus multi-shade variety, and lower-maintenance retractable tips versus pencils that need a sharpener for a finer point. Some sets also mix eye, brow, or shadow uses, so checking the intended application matters. Read on for the full breakdown and help choosing the right format for your routine.
Get beauty and skincare favorites delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Maybelline Unstoppable stands out as the everyday black-liner pick, while IT Cosmetics Superhero serves buyers willing to prioritize a premium single-pencil option.
- NYX Mechanical Lip Liner is the dedicated lip choice; most other products here are eyeliners or mixed-use sets, so they are not direct substitutes.
- The large color assortments trade a more tailored everyday choice for breadth; they make more sense for experimenting or varied looks than for a buyer who only needs black liner.
- Built-in sharpeners, as on the L’Oréal Infallible Never Fail, can help maintain a usable point, but add a component that simple twist-up pencils do not have.
- The list includes sets labeled for brow, eyeliner, eyeshadow, or mixed use; buyers should match the product’s stated purpose to the area they plan to apply it.
| Nabi Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils, Black, 12-Pack |  | Best Bulk Pick for Black Eyeliner | Brand: Nabi | Product type: Retractable eyeliner pencils | Color: Black | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Lip Liner Pencil, Nude Pink |  | Best Retractable Lip-Liner Pick | Product type: Mechanical lip liner pencil | Shade: Nude Pink | Design: Twist-up; no sharpener needed | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 20-Piece Retractable Colorful Eyeliner Pencil Set |  | Best for Color Variety | Pieces: 20 | Format: Retractable pencils | Finish: Matte | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 12-Piece Retractable Eyeliner Pencil Set with Sharpener |  | Best for Vivid Multi-Use Looks | Set contents: 12 eyeliner pencils and 1 sharpener | Color range: 12 vivid shades | Formula: Waterproof and smudge-resistant | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil, Onyx Black |  | Best for Sensitive-Eye Shoppers | Brand: Maybelline | Product type: Mechanical eyeliner pencil | Color: Onyx black | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Black |  | Best for Waterline Wear | Brand: e.l.f. | Product type: Retractable eyeliner | Color: Black | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| L’Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail Mechanical Pencil Eyeliner with Built-In Sharpener, Brown, 0.008 oz |  | Best for Smoky Looks | Brand: L’Oréal Paris | Product type: Mechanical pencil eyeliner | Shade: Brown | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Retractable Eyeliner Pencils, 20 Colors |  | Best for Color Variety | Quantity: 20 pencils | Format: Retractable eyeliner pencils | Texture: Soft and creamy | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Evpct 12-Piece Matte Colored Eyeliner Pencil Set |  | Best for Matte Multicolor Looks | Quantity: 12 pencils | Finish: Matte | Colors: White, black, green, blue, yellow, orange, auburn, palm, purple, coffee, cyan, and pink | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 12-Piece Retractable Eyebrow and Eyeliner Pencil Set |  | Best for Multi-Use Experimentation | Quantity: 12 pieces | Format: Retractable pencils | Suggested uses: Eyeliner, eyeshadow, and eyebrow pencil | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| NYX Professional Makeup Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil, Always Onyx |  | Best for Creamy, Vivid Definition | Product type: Retractable eyeliner pencil | Shade: Always Onyx | Color: Black | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner, Black |  | Best for Water-Resistant Wear | Product type: Retractable gel eyeliner | Color: Black | Formula: Satin gel | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 12-Color Waterproof Matte Gel Eyeliner Pencil Set |  | Best for Matte Color Variety | Quantity: 12 eyeliner pencils | Format: Retractable pencils | Formula: Gel | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Waterproof Retractable Eyeliner |  | Best for Lash-Line and Inner-Rim Use | Product type: Retractable eyeliner | Formula: Waterproof, long-wearing | Available shades: Black, Brown, Silk Taupe | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 8-Piece Retractable Creamy Eyeliner and Eyeshadow Stick Set |  | Best for Two-in-One Eye Looks | Set size: 8 pieces | Colors: Black, white, brown, blue, purple, green, and gray | Use: Eyeliner and eyeshadow | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| retractable makeup pen | Formula | Product type |
|---|---|---|
| Nabi Retractable Waterproof Ey | — | Retractable eyeliner pencils |
| NYX Professional Makeup Mechan | Creamy and richly pigmented | Mechanical lip liner pencil |
| 20-Piece Retractable Colorful | — | — |
| 12-Piece Retractable Eyeliner | Waterproof and smudge-resistant | — |
| Maybelline Unstoppable Waterpr | Waterproof and smudge-resistant | Mechanical eyeliner pencil |
| e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Ey | Creamy and highly pigmented | Retractable eyeliner |
| L’Oréal Paris Infallible Never | Rich and creamy | Mechanical pencil eyeliner |
| Retractable Eyeliner Pencils | — | — |
| Evpct 12-Piece Matte Colored E | — | — |
| 12-Piece Retractable Eyebrow a | — | — |
| NYX Professional Makeup Vivid | Creamy, highly pigmented | Retractable eyeliner pencil |
| wet n wild Mega Last Breakup P | Satin gel | Retractable gel eyeliner |
| 12-Color Waterproof Matte Gel | Gel | — |
| IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug | Waterproof, long-wearing | Retractable eyeliner |
| 8-Piece Retractable Creamy Eye | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Nabi Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils, Black, 12-Pack
The 12-pack format makes Nabi a practical choice for someone who reaches for black liner often or wants matching pencils in multiple bags. Its twist-up barrel removes the need for sharpening, while the built-in smudger lets you soften a line into a smoky look without carrying a separate tool. The creamy formula is described as waterproof and smudge-proof, a useful combination for humid or active days, though the listing provides no wear-duration details. Compared with Maybelline Unstoppable, Nabi adds a smudger and extra pencils, while Maybelline specifies a self-sharpening tip, a stated wear time, and suitability for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Nabi’s main tradeoff is its narrow color choice: this is a supply-focused black-liner buy, not a versatile color set.
Pros:- Twist-up design needs no separate sharpener.
- Built-in smudger supports smoky or softened lines.
- Creamy formula is described as easy to glide.
- Twelve matching pencils suit frequent use or keeping extras in different places.
Cons:- Only black is specified, limiting color variety.
- No wear duration or independent performance details are provided.
- The listing does not specify suitability for sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers.
Best for: Regular black-eyeliner users who want a dozen twist-up pencils and a built-in tool for softening the line.
Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking several shades or a clearly stated wear duration; the listing specifies black only and gives no hours-of-wear claim.
- Brand:Nabi
- Product type:Retractable eyeliner pencils
- Color:Black
- Quantity:12
- Waterproof:Yes
- Smudge-proof:Yes
- Built-in smudger:Yes
- Sharpening required:No
Our verdict“Choose Nabi if you want a bulk supply of retractable black liner with a smudger, but choose Maybelline if stated wear time and sensitive-eye suitability matter more.”
NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Lip Liner Pencil, Nude Pink
Unlike the other picks here, the NYX Mechanical Lip Liner is identified as a lip product, so it suits a roundup reader who specifically wants a retractable makeup pencil for defining lips rather than eyes. Its twist-up, no-sharpener design is convenient for touch-ups, and the creamy, richly pigmented formula is intended to give visible color without a separate pencil sharpener. Compared with the Nabi and Maybelline options, which are described as eyeliners, this is the more relevant choice for lip definition—but it does not offer their eye-specific claims about waterproofness or wear. There is a listing inconsistency that refers to use for lips or eyes, so I would treat it as a lip liner based on its product name and description rather than assume dual use. The Nude Pink shade also makes it less flexible than a multi-shade set.
Pros:- Twist-up mechanical barrel needs no sharpener.
- Creamy, richly pigmented formula is described in the listing.
- Nude Pink offers a defined shade choice for lip looks.
- The brand describes its cosmetics as cruelty-free.
Cons:- Product details conflict about whether the pencil is for lips or eyes.
- Only Nude Pink is specified for this listing.
- No waterproofness or wear-duration information is provided.
Best for: Shoppers looking for a twist-up nude-pink lip liner and who prefer a creamy, pigmented pencil over a sharpenable format.
Not ideal for: Anyone shopping specifically for retractable eyeliner or relying on clear waterproof and wear-time claims; the listed product is a lip liner and those claims are absent.
- Product type:Mechanical lip liner pencil
- Shade:Nude Pink
- Design:Twist-up; no sharpener needed
- Formula:Creamy and richly pigmented
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Shade availability:Available in a range of shades, according to the description
Our verdict“Pick this NYX pencil for retractable nude-pink lip definition, not as a substitute for the eye-focused Nabi or Maybelline liners.”
20-Piece Retractable Colorful Eyeliner Pencil Set
This set is the clear choice for shoppers who want many colors in one purchase rather than a dependable everyday black pencil. The 20 retractable pencils cover assorted shades, including black, white, silver, blue, green, purple, red, and pink; the listing also describes them for use as eyeliner, eyeshadow, or highlight. That flexibility gives the set a broader creative role than Nabi’s 12 black pencils, while the matte finish is a different direction from the multi-use, vividly colored set with a sharpener. The tradeoff is limited performance detail: the listing says the pencils are designed for precise application and quick drying but gives no wear-time or removal information. I would choose these for experimentation, parties, or costume looks, not when a specific long-wear formula is the priority.
Pros:- Twenty pencils provide a broad assortment of colors.
- The listed uses include eyeliner, eyeshadow, and highlight.
- Retractable format avoids needing a separate sharpener.
- Designed for everyday makeup as well as parties, performances, and costume looks.
Cons:- No wear-time information is given.
- The listing does not explain how the formula removes.
- The set’s broad creative use may be less useful to someone who only wants a single everyday shade.
Best for: Makeup enthusiasts, performers, and costume users who want a wide assortment of retractable colors for liner and other creative looks.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need documented wear time, removal guidance, or one reliable shade for daily wear; those details are not provided.
- Pieces:20
- Format:Retractable pencils
- Finish:Matte
- Colors:Assorted, including black, white, silver, blue, green, purple, red, and pink
- Uses:Eyeliner, eyeshadow, and highlight
- Application:Designed for precise application and quick drying
Our verdict“Choose this set for experimenting with color and multi-use looks, but favor Maybelline Unstoppable or Nabi if a black liner with more specific performance claims is your priority.”
12-Piece Retractable Eyeliner Pencil Set with Sharpener
This 12-pencil set stands out for pairing vivid shades with a stated waterproof, smudge-resistant formula and several suggested uses. The pencils are described as eyeliner, eyeshadow base, or lip liner, so the set offers more ways to use its colors than Maybelline’s single Onyx Black pencil. It also includes a sharpener, an unusual addition for a retractable format that may help refine the tip, though the listing does not explain how or when to use it. At 1.4 g per pencil, each stick is compact; the tradeoff is that the description warns some users may experience redness, itching, or discomfort. Color appearance may also vary with lighting and monitor settings. Compared with the 20-piece colorful set, this one has fewer shades but clearer water- and smudge-resistance claims.
Pros:- Twelve vivid shades support varied makeup looks.
- Formula is described as waterproof and smudge-resistant.
- Listed for use as eyeliner, eyeshadow base, or lip liner.
- Includes a sharpener despite the retractable pencil format.
Cons:- The listing warns of possible redness, itching, or discomfort for some users.
- Shade appearance may vary with lighting and monitor settings.
- The description does not provide a wear duration.
Best for: Shoppers who want a compact set of vivid retractable pencils with stated water and smudge resistance and options for eye or lip looks.
Not ideal for: People with easily irritated skin or eyes, and buyers who want a single established black liner rather than a multi-shade set.
- Set contents:12 eyeliner pencils and 1 sharpener
- Color range:12 vivid shades
- Formula:Waterproof and smudge-resistant
- Additional uses:Eyeliner, eyeshadow base, or lip liner
- Pencil size:15 x 0.8 x 0.8 cm (5.9 x 0.3 x 0.3 in)
- Net weight per pencil:1.4 g (0.05 oz)
- Item weight:116 g
- Package size:15.5 x 6 x 2 cm (6.1 x 2.4 x 0.8 in)
Our verdict“Choose this set over the 20-piece color set when stated water resistance and multi-use claims matter more than having the largest shade assortment.”
Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil, Onyx Black
Maybelline is the most focused everyday pick in this group: a single Onyx Black mechanical liner with a self-sharpening tip, a waterproof and smudge-resistant formula, and a stated wear time of up to 24 hours. The listing also identifies it as ophthalmologist tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, details that make it more targeted than Nabi’s bulk black set, whose listing gives no comparable suitability or duration information. The self-sharpening design favors a defined point, while Nabi offers a built-in smudger for a softer finish. That difference makes Maybelline the better match for crisp, long-wear definition, not smoky application or color variety. It is a single-shade pencil, and the supplied product data gives no drawbacks beyond that limited range.
Pros:- Waterproof, smudge-resistant formula.
- Self-sharpening tip supports a defined application.
- Listed as ophthalmologist tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
- Wear time is stated as up to 24 hours.
Cons:- Only Onyx Black is specified.
- The listing does not provide a built-in smudger or multi-pencil set.
- No other drawbacks are supplied in the product data.
Best for: Contact lens wearers and shoppers with sensitive eyes who want a black mechanical liner with stated water resistance and wear time.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking multiple shades, a bulk set, or a built-in smudger for smoky looks; this listing covers one black pencil and specifies a self-sharpening tip instead.
- Brand:Maybelline
- Product type:Mechanical eyeliner pencil
- Color:Onyx black
- Formula:Waterproof and smudge-resistant
- Tip:Self-sharpening
- Wear time:Up to 24 hours
- Suitable for:Sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
Our verdict“Choose Maybelline for a single black liner with the clearest sensitive-eye and wear-time claims here, but choose Nabi if you want multiple pencils and a smudger.”
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Black
The e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner stands out for buyers who want one black pencil for the lash line, waterline, and lid. Its creamy, highly pigmented formula is designed to resist water and wear, giving it a more focused everyday role than the L’Oréal Paris Infallible pencil, whose built-in smudger and sharpener favor changing or softening the look. This one can also work as an eyeshadow base, so it offers more than a single fine-line use. The tradeoff is that the supplied details do not specify a wear-time duration or include a sharpening accessory. Choose it for versatile black definition and vegan, cruelty-free credentials; skip it if you want a built-in tool for smoky blending or precise tip maintenance.
Pros:- Creamy, highly pigmented black formula
- Designed to resist water and wear
- Can be applied to the lash line, waterline, or eyelid as an eyeshadow base
- Vegan and cruelty-free
Cons:- No built-in smudger or sharpener is listed
- The product details do not give a specific wear-time duration
Best for: Makeup wearers seeking a black retractable pencil for lash-line, waterline, and lid application, with vegan and cruelty-free credentials.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a built-in smudger or sharpener, or need a stated wear-time duration before choosing.
- Brand:e.l.f.
- Product type:Retractable eyeliner
- Color:Black
- Formula:Creamy and highly pigmented
- Wear claims:Designed to resist water and wear
- Suggested uses:Lash line, waterline, eyelid, and eyeshadow base
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-free:Yes
Our verdict“Choose this for versatile black definition across the lash line, waterline, and lid; pick the L’Oréal pencil instead if a built-in smudger matters more.”
L’Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail Mechanical Pencil Eyeliner with Built-In Sharpener, Brown, 0.008 oz
The L’Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail is the most tool-ready option here for anyone who likes to soften liner after drawing it. Its built-in smudger and sharpener support classic definition as well as bold or smoky looks, while the creamy brown formula is designed to glide on and resist fading and smudging for up to 16 hours. Compared with the e.l.f. No Budge, which emphasizes water resistance and use on the waterline, this pencil makes blending and tip upkeep its clearest advantage. Its brown shade also gives a less stark alternative to the e.l.f. black. The tradeoff is the small 0.008 oz amount, and the product carries a warning against use on scratched, infected, or irritated eyes.
Pros:- Built-in smudger supports smoky and softened looks
- Built-in sharpener helps maintain the tip
- Creamy formula is described as gliding on easily
- Designed for smudge-proof, fade-resistant wear up to 16 hours
Cons:- Brown shade may not suit buyers who want classic black liner
- Small listed quantity of 0.008 oz
- Includes a warning against use on scratched, infected, or irritated eyes
Best for: People who want a brown liner with built-in tools for softening the line and maintaining the pencil tip.
Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking black eyeliner, waterline-focused claims, or a product without the stated eye-injury warning.
- Brand:L’Oréal Paris
- Product type:Mechanical pencil eyeliner
- Shade:Brown
- Weight:0.008 oz
- Wear time:Up to 16 hours, as described
- Built-in tools:Sharpener and smudger
- Formula:Rich and creamy
- Wear claims:Smudge-proof and fade-resistant
Our verdict“Pick this brown mechanical pencil if built-in blending and sharpening matter more than the e.l.f. No Budge’s waterline-focused versatility.”
Retractable Eyeliner Pencils, 20 Colors
This 20-pencil retractable set is the broadest color-and-finish choice in this group, with matte and pearlescent options that can serve as liner, eyeshadow, or highlighter. That range gives it a different purpose from the Evpct 12-piece matte set: Evpct centers on matte colors and also lists lip- and brow-pencil uses, while this set pairs its larger assortment with two finishes and eye-area highlighting. The soft, creamy texture is described as blendable, which suits buyers who want to experiment with more than a crisp line. The tradeoff is uncertainty: no independent performance details are supplied to substantiate the smudge-proof, all-day-wear claims, and the assortment may be more than someone needs for a simple daily liner.
Pros:- Includes 20 retractable pencils
- Offers matte and pearlescent finishes
- Soft, creamy texture is described as smooth and blendable
- Pencils can also be used as eyeshadow or highlighter
Cons:- No independent performance details are provided for the wear claims
- The supplied details do not identify individual colors
- Large assortment may be unnecessary for buyers focused on one everyday shade
Best for: Makeup experimenters who want a large retractable color selection with both matte and pearlescent finishes for liner, shadow, and highlighting.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want verified wear performance, a clearly itemized shade list, or just one dependable everyday pencil.
- Quantity:20 pencils
- Format:Retractable eyeliner pencils
- Texture:Soft and creamy
- Finishes:Matte and pearlescent
- Suggested uses:Eyeliner, eyeshadow, and highlighter
- Wear description:Described as smudge-proof and all-day wear
Our verdict“Choose this set for broad color and finish variety, but favor a single-shade option if documented wear performance is your priority.”
Evpct 12-Piece Matte Colored Eyeliner Pencil Set
The Evpct 12-piece set suits buyers who want matte color beyond the usual black-and-brown rotation. Its listed shades span neutrals and brights, and the pencils are described as usable not only for eyeliner but also for lip liner, eyeshadow, and eyebrow work. Compared with the 20-color retractable set, Evpct offers fewer pencils and no pearlescent finish, but gives a more specific matte-color focus and names its shades. The description also claims waterproof, smudge-resistant wear and says makeup remover can remove the pencils. Those claims lack independent performance details, and the product information does not give pencil dimensions or clarify each shade individually. Treat the multi-use claims as a convenience, not proof that every color is suitable for every area.
Pros:- Includes 12 matte colors spanning neutral and bright shades
- Soft pencils are described as applying smoothly
- Listed for use as eyeliner, lip liner, eyeshadow, and eyebrow pencil
- Described as waterproof and smudge-resistant
Cons:- Pencil dimensions are not provided
- Individual shade details beyond the color list are limited
- Longevity claims are not supported by independent performance details
Best for: Makeup users who want a named assortment of matte colors for experimenting across eyeliner and other makeup applications.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who need detailed shade-by-shade information, pencil dimensions, or independently supported wear claims.
- Quantity:12 pencils
- Finish:Matte
- Colors:White, black, green, blue, yellow, orange, auburn, palm, purple, coffee, cyan, and pink
- Waterproof:Claimed
- Smudge resistance:Claimed
- Suggested uses:Eyeliner, lip liner, eyeshadow, and eyebrow pencil
- Removal:Makeup remover
Our verdict“Choose Evpct for a matte-focused, multicolor set with listed shade names; choose the 20-color set if pearlescent options matter more.”
12-Piece Retractable Eyebrow and Eyeliner Pencil Set
This 12-piece retractable set is the most flexible-use pick on paper: the pencils are described for eyeliner, eyeshadow, and eyebrow application, with quick-drying and water-resistant performance claimed by the seller. That broad positioning may appeal to someone building a varied eye-makeup kit, but it is less specific than the Evpct set, which lists its colors and matte finish, or the L’Oréal pencil, which provides a shade, weight, wear-time claim, and built-in tools. Here, the color list and ingredients are not supplied, so it is hard to plan a palette or judge suitability in advance. The seller offers replacement or refunds for unsatisfied purchases, but that does not fill the gaps in product detail. Treat its performance claims cautiously.
Pros:- Includes 12 retractable pencils
- Listed for eyeliner, eyeshadow, and eyebrow use
- Seller claims a quick-drying formula
- Seller claims water resistance
Cons:- Specific colors are not listed
- Ingredients are not provided
- Water-resistance and anti-allergy claims are not independently verified
Best for: Budget-conscious makeup experimenters who want a multi-piece retractable set for trying eyeliner, shadow, and brow applications.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need to know the exact shades or ingredients, or who require independently supported water-resistance claims.
- Quantity:12 pieces
- Format:Retractable pencils
- Suggested uses:Eyeliner, eyeshadow, and eyebrow pencil
- Water resistance:Claimed
- Drying:Described as quick-drying
- Color details:Not specified
- Ingredients:Not specified
Our verdict“Choose this set for broad, low-commitment experimentation, but pick the Evpct set if a stated color assortment matters to you.”
NYX Professional Makeup Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil, Always Onyx
Always Onyx is a good fit if you want a retractable pencil that lays down strong black color without sharpening. Its creamy formula is designed to glide along the lash line, making it better suited to quick definition or a more graphic wing than a firm, precision-first pencil. NYX describes it as resistant to smudging and humidity, though the supplied details give no wear-time figure and do not claim waterproof performance. Compared with wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof, this pencil offers matte, shimmer, and metallic shade options across the range, while wet n wild provides clearer waterproof and wear-duration claims. I’d choose NYX for texture and finish choice, but skip it if water resistance is your main requirement.
Pros:- Retractable format avoids routine sharpening
- Creamy formula is designed to glide smoothly
- Highly pigmented black shade supports vivid definition
- Cruelty-free
Cons:- No specific wear duration is provided
- Waterproof performance is not claimed
Best for: Makeup users who want a smooth, pigmented black liner and may want to explore matte, shimmer, or metallic finishes in the range.
Not ideal for: Anyone who needs a clearly stated waterproof formula or a specified wear duration for long, wet, or humid days.
- Product type:Retractable eyeliner pencil
- Shade:Always Onyx
- Color:Black
- Formula:Creamy, highly pigmented
- Finish options:Matte, shimmer, and metallic shades
- Sharpening:Not required
- Cruelty-free:Yes
Our verdict“Choose Always Onyx for creamy, vivid retractable definition, but pick wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof if explicit waterproof wear claims matter more.”
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner, Black
For buyers who prioritize staying power over a wide shade selection, wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof has the clearest performance claims in this group: it is described as waterproof, smudge-proof, cry-proof, and humidity-proof, with wear of up to 16 hours. The satin gel formula is also intended to glide without tugging, which can make lining the lash line feel more comfortable than a drier pencil. Compared with NYX Vivid Rich, wet n wild gives a more specific account of wear and water resistance, while NYX offers a broader range of finish options. The tradeoff is a more focused proposition: the supplied product details list black only and do not describe blending time or how easily the liner removes. I’d favor it for demanding wear days, not for shoppers seeking multiple finishes.
Pros:- Waterproof, smudge-proof, cry-proof, and humidity-proof claims
- Wear is stated as up to 16 hours
- Silky satin gel formula is designed to glide without tugging
- Cruelty-free and vegan
Cons:- The supplied details list only black
- No guidance is provided on blending or removal
Best for: People who need a black retractable liner with stated waterproof, humidity-resistant, and long-wear claims for busy or tear-prone days.
Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for multiple colors or finish choices, or those who want detailed guidance on blending and removal.
- Product type:Retractable gel eyeliner
- Color:Black
- Formula:Satin gel
- Wear time:Up to 16 hours
- Water resistance:Waterproof
- Wear claims:Smudge-proof, cry-proof, and humidity-proof
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Vegan:Yes
Our verdict“Pick wet n wild for the strongest stated wear and water-resistance claims here, rather than NYX if finish variety is your priority.”
12-Color Waterproof Matte Gel Eyeliner Pencil Set
This 12-pencil set is the lineup’s broadest dedicated eyeliner assortment, making it a fit for people who want color options for everyday looks and more creative designs. All pencils are described as retractable gel liners with a matte finish, so the set is more consistent in look than the 8-piece eyeliner-and-eyeshadow set, which mixes matte and satin finishes and has dual-use pencils. Its waterproof, smudge-, sweat-, and transfer-resistant claims are appealing, and the stated wear is up to 24 hours. That duration is a claim in the supplied description, not an independently verified result; there are also no wear-test details to help judge how the colors perform across different skin types. I’d choose it for breadth of matte liner shades, not for proven all-day performance.
Pros:- Includes 12 eyeliner pencils in varied colors
- Matte gel formula is designed to glide smoothly
- Described as waterproof and resistant to smudging, sweat, and transfer
- Vegan and cruelty-free claims
Cons:- Up-to-24-hour wear claim is not independently verified
- No customer or wear-test details are supplied
- All pencils share a matte finish, limiting finish variety
Best for: Makeup users who want a varied collection of matte eyeliner colors for coordinated, colorful, or creative looks.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need independent wear-test evidence, prefer a smaller color selection, or want pencils that double as eyeshadow sticks.
- Quantity:12 eyeliner pencils
- Format:Retractable pencils
- Formula:Gel
- Finish:Matte
- Waterproof:Yes
- Wear time:Up to 24 hours (claimed)
- Resistance claims:Smudge-, sweat-, and transfer-resistant
- Ethical claims:Vegan and cruelty-free
Our verdict“Choose this set over the 8-piece dual-use sticks if you want more dedicated matte eyeliner colors, while treating its extended-wear claim as unverified.”
IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Waterproof Retractable Eyeliner
Superhero No-Tug stands out for application flexibility: it is described for use along both the lash line and inner rims, with a waterproof formula that sets after application. That makes it more targeted than the 12-color matte set, which emphasizes variety, and more versatile in placement than a product described only for lash-line looks. The twist-up design also avoids sharpening, while the formula can be blended for softer definition. The catch is timing: once it sets, blending becomes harder, so I’d work one eye at a time and soften the line immediately. Three shades—black, brown, and silk taupe—give useful basic options, but shoppers seeking a broad color palette should look to the larger sets instead.
Pros:- Designed for both lash-line and inner-rim application
- Waterproof, long-wearing formula
- Twist-up format requires no sharpening
- Can be blended for softer definition before it sets
Cons:- Sets after application, leaving a short blending window
- Only three available shades are listed
- No specific wear duration is provided
Best for: People who want a waterproof retractable pencil for lash-line or inner-rim definition, with the option to soften the line right after application.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who like to blend slowly or want a large selection of bright or unconventional shades.
- Product type:Retractable eyeliner
- Formula:Waterproof, long-wearing
- Available shades:Black, Brown, Silk Taupe
- Application:Twist up; apply along lash line or inner rims
- Sharpening:Not required
- Blending:Can be blended before setting
- Setting behavior:Sets after application
Our verdict“Choose Superhero No-Tug for waterproof inner-rim and lash-line use if you can blend promptly; choose the 12-color set for more shade variety.”
8-Piece Retractable Creamy Eyeliner and Eyeshadow Stick Set
These eight retractable sticks are the most flexible pick for someone who wants one pencil to line and shade the eyes. Their creamy gel texture and matte or satin finishes suit both defined lines and broader, blended color, unlike the 12-Color Waterproof Matte Gel set, which is positioned as eyeliner only and keeps a single finish. The set includes black, white, brown, blue, purple, green, and gray, though the description does not specify the exact distribution across all eight pencils. Waterproof and smudge-resistant performance is claimed, but the supplied details provide no wear duration or independent testing. I’d choose these for a compact multi-use color assortment, while buyers who want more dedicated liner shades may prefer the 12-pencil set.
Pros:- Pencils are designed for both eyeliner and eyeshadow use
- Retractable twist-up format requires no sharpening
- Includes multiple colors and matte or satin finishes
- Creamy gel texture is described as easy to apply
Cons:- Waterproof and wear claims are not independently verified
- No wear duration is provided
- Ingredient and pencil-size details are absent
Best for: Makeup users who want retractable pencils for both eyeliner and eyeshadow, with several color and finish options in one set.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need verified waterproof or long-wear performance, exact pencil-size details, or a large assortment of dedicated liner shades.
- Set size:8 pieces
- Colors:Black, white, brown, blue, purple, green, and gray
- Use:Eyeliner and eyeshadow
- Format:Retractable twist-up mechanical pencils
- Texture:Creamy gel
- Finish:Matte and satin
- Formula claims:Waterproof and smudge-resistant
- Ethical claims:Vegan and cruelty-free
Our verdict“Pick this set over the 12-color eyeliner set if dual-use sticks matter more than a larger, eyeliner-only matte palette.”
How We Picked
I compared these 15 products by the needs signaled in their names and formats: intended use, retractable convenience, shade range, waterproof or wear claims, included sharpeners, and whether a product is a single pencil or a multi-piece set. I gave more weight to clear everyday utility and a specific role than to a large piece count alone. A dedicated lip liner, for example, should be judged as a lip product rather than as a replacement for black eyeliner.
The ranking favors options with a clear use case and a manageable tradeoff. The Maybelline pencil leads as an accessible everyday eyeliner choice; NYX Mechanical Lip Liner and IT Cosmetics Superhero rank for distinct needs, not because they serve the same buyer. Sets place lower for shoppers seeking one dependable daily pencil, but can suit people who value shade variety. Product names alone cannot establish wear time, ingredient suitability, or performance on sensitive eyes, so buyers should verify current packaging and manufacturer guidance.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Retractable Makeup Pens
Retractable packaging is only one part of the decision. I would start with where the pencil will go, how precise the line needs to be, and whether a single shade or a palette-style assortment better fits your routine.
Match the pencil to the application
Eye, lip, brow, and eyeshadow pencils are not interchangeable just because they share a twist-up barrel. Choose a product whose label names the area you plan to use it on, and follow its directions. A lip liner is designed around lip definition, while an eyeliner is meant for eye looks; a mixed-use set may still have limits by shade or formula. A common mistake is buying a multi-purpose-looking set without checking which pencils are intended for which areas. If your routine centers on one application, a dedicated pencil is usually a clearer choice than a broad set. For use close to the waterline or on sensitive eyes, check the brand’s instructions and ingredient information rather than assuming every eyeliner is suitable.
Choose single pencils or color sets by how you actually wear makeup
A single black or brown pencil is often easier to use consistently than a set with a dozen or more shades. Color assortments such as the 20-color sets and Evpct matte set offer more room to experiment, but extra shades can go unused if your routine is simple. Before choosing a large set, think about whether you want neutrals, bright colors, or a particular finish; the number of pencils does not tell you how wearable the shades will be. Sets can be useful for creative looks, travel kits shared across looks, or replacing several colors at once. They are less suited to someone who wants one reliable everyday line and minimal storage. For that buyer, a focused single pencil may offer better practical value even without variety.
Treat waterproof claims as a use-case choice
Waterproof labeling can matter for humid weather, watery eyes, or long days, but it may also make removal more involved. Check the product’s removal directions and use a remover suited to eye makeup rather than rubbing at delicate skin. Waterproof wording does not tell you exactly how a formula will behave on your skin, so avoid treating it as a guarantee of identical wear for everyone. If easy removal is a priority, a pencil without a waterproof claim may be a better fit. Compare the claim with your routine: occasional outdoor wear and daily use may call for different tradeoffs. Patch-testing and following the label are sensible steps, particularly for sensitive skin.
Decide how much point control you need
Retractable pencils reduce the need to carry a separate sharpener, but their tips may not offer the same degree of point adjustment as a sharpenable pencil. That difference matters when you want a very fine line, crisp lip edges, or a softer smudged look. The L’Oréal Infallible model includes a built-in sharpener, which adds a way to refresh the point while keeping the tool self-contained. A sharpener also means another component to maintain and use carefully. Avoid extending a twist-up tip farther than needed; a more exposed tip can be easier to break. If precision is central to your routine, check how the product is designed to shape or refresh its tip.
Compare convenience with the set’s storage and maintenance needs
Retractable packaging is handy for a makeup bag, but multi-pencil sets take more space and can make shade identification less simple. Look for clear shade labeling and a container that keeps tips protected, especially if you plan to carry the pencils. A built-in sharpener can reduce the need for extra tools, while a basic twist-up pencil keeps the design simpler. With either format, cap the pencil after use and follow the maker’s storage guidance. Do not share eye or lip pencils without following appropriate hygiene practices, and replace products according to their labeling. The best convenience is the kind that matches your routine, not simply the one with the most pieces.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are retractable makeup pens suitable for both lips and eyes?
Not by default. This roundup includes a dedicated lip liner, several eye pencils, and sets that mention brow or eyeshadow use, so the intended application varies. Use each product only as directed on its packaging, particularly around the eyes. A pencil that twists up may look similar across categories, but that does not mean its formula or use guidance is the same. If you need both lip and eye products, choose clearly labeled pencils for each area.
Should I choose a waterproof pencil if I have sensitive eyes?
Waterproof labeling describes a wear-related claim, not whether a product will suit sensitive eyes. Read the ingredient list and manufacturer directions, and check whether the product is approved for the area where you plan to apply it. If you have a history of irritation, ask a qualified clinician for advice and try new products cautiously. Waterproof formulas may call for a suitable remover, so include removal comfort in your decision. Stop using a product if irritation develops.
Is a multi-color eyeliner set a better buy than one pencil?
It depends on whether you will use the shades. The 20-color and 12-piece sets in this roundup offer variety, while a single pencil such as Maybelline Unstoppable is more directly suited to a focused everyday routine. A set can make sense if you regularly change colors or create different looks, but unused shades add clutter rather than useful choice. Check the shade descriptions and finishes before selecting by piece count alone. If you mostly wear one neutral, a single pencil is the simpler match.
What is the benefit of a built-in sharpener on a retractable pencil?
A built-in sharpener can help refresh a point when the tip becomes rounded, which may be useful for finer lines or more defined edges. The L’Oréal Infallible model in this roundup is the option explicitly described with one. It does not remove the need to follow the product’s instructions, and it adds a part to keep clean and use carefully. If you prefer a simple twist-up format and do not need a particularly fine point, a pencil without a sharpener may be less fussy. Compare point control with ease of maintenance rather than treating the sharpener as an automatic upgrade.
Which retractable makeup pen makes the most sense for a beginner?
A beginner who wants a straightforward eye look may prefer a single neutral eyeliner rather than a large assortment with many unfamiliar shades. Maybelline Unstoppable is the roundup’s everyday black-pencil pick, while NYX Mechanical Lip Liner is a better match for someone learning to define lips. Start with the application you use most and check the product label before applying it. A large set can be appealing, but more choices may make it harder to settle on a routine. Beginners who want to experiment with color can still choose a set, provided its intended uses and shade descriptions are clear.
Conclusion
For an everyday black eyeliner, I recommend Maybelline Unstoppable as the best overall pick; for a dedicated lip pencil, choose NYX Mechanical Lip Liner. Buyers seeking a premium option can look to IT Cosmetics Superhero, while the multi-pencil assortments are the best-value direction for shoppers who will use several shades rather than just one. Beginners are better served by starting with a single, clearly labeled neutral pencil, then adding colors once they know what they reach for. For specific needs, pick L’Oréal if a built-in sharpener matters, or a larger set if color variety is the priority. The right choice depends less on the retractable format itself than on matching the pencil’s intended use and tradeoffs to your routine.
